What is TB resistance?
Breeding cattle for greater resistance to bovine tuberculosis (TB) can help reduce the risk of TB reactors and herd breakdowns over time.
Some cattle are naturally more resistant to TB than others because of their genetics. Cattle with greater genetic resistance to TB have a better ability to resist infection.
Selecting for TB resistance can support Ireland’s national TB eradication programme by helping to reduce the number of TB reactors and herd breakdowns over time. It is a long-term breeding strategy that works alongside existing TB control measures, including TB testing and biosecurity.
Understanding TB PTA
TB resistance is expressed as a Predicted Transmitting Ability (PTA %). The TB PTA indicates the expected prevalence of TB reactors among an animal’s progeny.
Lower TB PTA values are more desirable, as they indicate progeny that are less likely to become TB reactors.
For example:
| Bull | TB PTA | Expected TB reactors |
|---|---|---|
| Bull A | 9% | 9 in every 100 progeny |
| Bull B | 2% | 2 in every 100 progeny |
Remember: lower is better. A bull with a lower TB PTA is more desirable for TB resistance. Based on TB resistance alone, Bull B would therefore be the preferred choice.
Did you know?
Cattle with the poorest genetic merit for TB resistance were approximately 26% more likely to become TB reactors than cattle with the best genetic merit for TB resistance when exposed to similar infection pressure.
Using TB PTA when selecting bulls
Even if a herd has never experienced a TB breakdown, animals can still receive a TB genetic evaluation. Information from relatives, pedigree, genomics and available TB data can be used to estimate an animal’s genetic resistance to TB.
TB resistance is included in the Economic Breeding Index (EBI), EuroStar Indices and Dairy Beef Index (DBI). This allows herd owners to select for improved TB resistance while continuing to make genetic progress in other economically important traits.
However, TB PTA should still be considered when selecting individual bulls. Bulls with high overall genetic merit can have either favourable or unfavourable TB PTA values. Farmers should therefore consider a bull’s TB PTA alongside its overall breeding index.
Current ICBF breeding guidance recommends aiming to use bulls with a TB value below 8.5%, or below 6.5% for more rapid improvement in TB resistance.
Understanding the TB traffic-light system
ICBF uses a simple traffic-light system to make TB resistance information easier to interpret when selecting bulls.
🔴 Red: Poorer TB resistance – Avoid
🟠 Orange: Average TB resistance – Proceed with caution
🟢 Green: Better TB resistance – Good to go.
The colours divide animals according to their TB resistance, with animals in the best third shown in green and those in the poorest third shown in red.
The traffic-light colours are available on ICBF Active Bull Lists and in Sire Advice, helping farmers quickly identify bulls with more favourable TB resistance.
Tip: When comparing suitable bulls, look for a strong overall breeding index alongside a lower TB PTA.
Where can I find TB PTA information?
TB PTA information is available through a number of ICBF services and tools, including:
- ICBF Active Bull Lists
- Animal Search
- And when you Sign In to ICBF/HerdPlus, for your herd:
- EBI Profile
- Sire Advice
Key messages
- Lower TB PTA values are better and indicate animals with greater genetic resistance to TB.
- Select for low TB PTA alongside strong overall genetic merit when choosing breeding animals.
- Breeding for TB resistance can be incorporated alongside continued genetic progress in other important traits.
- TB PTA information is available through Active Bull Lists, Animal Search, EBI Profiles and Sire Advice.
- Genetic selection is a long-term approach that complements existing TB control measures such as testing and biosecurity.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a high or low TB PTA better?
Lower is better. A lower TB PTA indicates that fewer of an animal’s progeny are expected to become TB reactors.
Why does my animal have a TB PTA if my herd has never had a TB breakdown?
An animal’s genetic evaluation is not based solely on TB events within its own herd. Information from genetically related animals, along with pedigree, genomic and other available data, can be used to estimate its genetic resistance to TB.
Is there a single gene for TB resistance?
No. TB resistance is a complex genetic trait influenced by multiple regions of the genome, rather than one individual “TB gene”.
Does breeding for TB resistance replace TB testing and biosecurity?
No. Genetic selection is a long-term, complementary approach that works alongside existing TB control measures, including TB testing and biosecurity.
Scientific research on breeding for TB resistance
Research into the genetics of bovine TB resistance supports the development and use of genetic evaluations for TB resistance in Irish cattle.
Ring SC, Purfield DC, Good M, Breslin P, Ryan E, Blom A, et al. (2019). Variance components for bovine tuberculosis infection and multi-breed genome-wide association analysis using imputed whole genome sequence data. PLoS ONE 14(2): e0212067.
Read the research paper
Ring, S. & Berry, D. (2025). Breeding for Bovine Tuberculosis Resistance. Moorepark 2025 Open Day Book, Teagasc.
Read the Moorepark 2025 Open Day Book
Lanigan, S. & Ring, S. (2026). Breeding for resistance to bovine tuberculosis in Irish cattle. World Congress on Genetics Applied to Livestock Production Digital Archive 2026(1): 2285542.
Read the research paper
